Ep. 35: Wake Up
Sleeping Sickness: The Epidemic That Vanished and the Patients Left Behind
It put millions to sleep. Some of them never woke up. Others woke up wrong.
Between 1917 and 1928, a mysterious illness swept the globe, leaving its victims in states of suspended animation, rigid and unreachable, trapped somewhere between sleep and death. Doctors called it encephalitis lethargica. The world called it the sleeping sickness. And then, almost as quickly as it appeared, it was gone, leaving behind no clear cause, no confirmed treatment, and thousands of survivors warehoused in institutions for decades, largely forgotten.
In this episode, Crystal walks Andrea through one of medicine's most enduring unsolved puzzles: what encephalitis lethargica is, what it did to the people it touched, why it vanished, and what its long shadow tells us about the limits of what medicine thinks it understands.
0:06 Welcome to M4 Medicine, mystery, mayhem, and sometimes murder. I'm Andrea Marziano and RN with 35 years of experience across various fields. From direct patient care in hospitals to home health, geriatrics, and injury medicine, I face life, death, and everything in between. And I'm Crystal Miller and RN with 13 1/2 years of experience. My work spans home health, Hospice, emergency care, geriatrics, and occupational health. From the chaos of trauma based quiet moments with patients, I've seen stories that defy explanations. We've been friends for over 25 years and as nurses we've shared countless stories that have left us and our families speechless. Now we're bringing those stories and many more to you in medicine, mystery, mayhem, and sometimes murder.
0:53 Each week, we'll uncover cases that challenge the boundaries of medicine, sharing the human stories behind the science. From puzzling medical mysteries to shocking real life crimes, we'll bring you stories that'll leave you questioning everything you thought you knew while. We're both experiencing treats, nurses. We want to make it clear we're not here to give medical advice. This podcast is about storytelling, education and exploration, not diagnosing or treating medical conditions. This is medicine, mystery, mayhem and sometimes murder. Let's dive in. Hey, Crystal, how are you? I'm doing great. How are you? I am Well, thank you. I hear you have some exciting plans for today. I do. We have a hot date for tonight and it's actually kind of funny. Not what's a hot date?
1:36 I know what a hot date is. What is your hot? Date. Oh, OK, I see. Well, Max came up to me today and said, hey, after recording, why don't we go to Dave and Buster's? Oh wow. I know I'm like Dave and Buster's, which for people who are listening who don't know what that is, it's basically an arcade sort of skee ball experience with bar food. He said, I just wanted to play skee ball and play the basketball games and stuff. I'm like, we, the last time we played it was I think two years ago with our granddaughter Eliza. So after this, we're going to do that, probably have a cheeseburger or something. I just saw online that they have a happy hour during the hours we'll be there.
2:18 So I guess prices for games is lower and prices for beverages and food are lower. So we're going to go rocket old people and in the arcades, man. Awesome. I remember the first time I went to school, so I was sorely disappointed. Yeah, yeah, we probably will be too. But it's it's just something to do. We've been talking about how we really haven't been doing anything fun because mostly we've been concentrating on remodeling our cabin and reconstructing the garage, which, as you know, was hit by another tree. I was. Just going to say, yeah, remember that your your garage got hit by another tree. That's fantastic.
2:58 Super super cool. The damage isn't nearly as bad, so hopefully it won't be as costly either. Oh jeez, what a what a fun life. Yeah, yeah, I think it's just he says the universe is against him with the tree gods, so. Yeah, right. Our is that free trimming I think. Yeah, sounds like it anyway. Well, what do you have for us today? I'm excited. Well, today I'm going to talk about encephalitis lethargica. You may not be familiar with the phrase or the name, but there's actually a quite famous movie and book. The book was written by Oliver Sacks. It's called Awakenings.
3:39 The movie is also called Awakenings. It stars Robin Williams and Robert De Niro. And so for the podcast today, I'm going to direct you to watch that movie. And thank you. Good night. Excellent. Well, I know a lot about lethargia. So my sources are though my sources really are the the book Awakenings by Oliver Sacks, Constantine von Economo, original case descriptions, the NIH and NINDS on encephalitislethargicabrainfax.org and Howard Markel The Sleeping Sickness epidemic. Around 1919, something strange began happening in hospitals across Europe's Europe's Why?
4:21 Why? Doctors noticed patients who seemed to fall asleep in ways that defied explanation. At first it looked like severe fatigue, maybe influenza, maybe exhaustion from war 'cause you'll remember this was right around the time of World War One. But then something terrifying happened and the patients didn't wake up. Oh, yeah. So what's like everything? Well, like they. But they were alive. Yeah. But what's interesting is they would sometimes they would sit upright in their hospital bed, but their eyes with their eyes open. But they would. They were unmoving, and they were clearly not focusing on anything. Others would sleep for days, or I know, for days or for weeks. Some could be awakened briefly only to sink back into sleep almost immediately.
5:03 And others became rigid and motionless and seemingly trapped inside their own bodies. And Druggles. Druggles. Nope. Why? This is my life. Some Muggles. Doctors struggled to explain. They could not explain it with juggles. But wait, hold on. So these people would be in the hospital for other reasons, or they'd be in the hospital for the sleep issue and then just, you know, sleep. And honestly, a weeks long nap sounds pretty darn good. Right, Yeah. So they would come in with fatigue and then it it would progress and it would progress in different ways. It it's, we'll get into this a little, little bit later. So families that were bringing these patients in, they they called it the sleeping sickness.
5:47 And it's important that you recognize or the OR or listeners recognize that this isn't the same as the African sleeping sickness that's caused by seed sea flies. It's entirely different than a different, much more, much more mysterious. So roughly between 1916 and 1927, the strange neurological illness spread across the world, infecting more than 1,000,000 people and killing over half a million. Those who survived often did not truly recover. Some remained frozen, unable to move or speak for decades. And today, more than a century later, no one knows exactly what caused it. Oh my goodness. This is the story, like I said, of encephalitis lethargica, the forgotten epidemic that left people trapped in time. OK, the year was 1916.
6:33 Picture it. World War One had turned cities into battlefields, hospitals into overcrowded wards and medical staff into exhausted witnesses to endless suffering. This sounds like such a cheerful story for a horrible topic. Amid this turmoil, physicians in Vienna began seeing patients with unusual symptoms. So it wasn't, it wasn't Germany for us, it was Austria. Well, there you go so far. Patients started with something mild. A sore throat, headache for fever, fatigue. Then something strange would happen. They'd become overwhelmingly sleepy. Not the kind of tired you feel after a long shift or a sleepless night. This was something deeper. Patients would sleep for hours, then days, sometimes week.
7:16 When doctors shift them awake. They would respond slowly, speak briefly, then drift back into sleep as it pulled downward by gravity. Phenomenon puzzled physicians. In 1917, a neurologist named Constantine von Econombo say that Five Times Fast published the first detailed description of the illness, describing it as a previously unknown disease affecting the brain. He gave it a name, of course, Encephalitis lethargica. Translated literally, it means inflammation of the brain that causes lethargy. So translated more literally into lay people's terms, it means your brain is slowing and it makes you tired. Yeah, that's. Really tired? Yeah, but the name hardly captured the horror of what doctors were about to see. Within a few years, reports began appearing across Europe, France, Germany, Britain, and then the United States. The illness seemed to appear almost randomly. One town might see dozens of cases. Another nearby nearby town would see none. Patients ranged from children to adults, but many were young teenagers and people in their 20s. Doctors began to realize eventually they were witnessing a global epidemic.
8:24 And it's interesting because this epidemic was also around the same time as the Spanish Flu. I'll talk a little bit more about that in the future also. But it, it, this was interesting that there were potentially two. Well, I guess the, the Spanish Flu was a pandemic and this was a global epidemic, but still it's two things going on at the same time. And between 1915 and 1926, this encephalitis Lethargicus spread across continents and no one understood how it spread. Wow, May I ask a question real quick with the descriptor of encephalitis? Were they actually seeing inflammation in the brain? So. That's also something that I'll talk about. But yeah, they were but in autopsies. So they they weren't necessarily able to diagnose the encephalitis itself from living patients, but they were able to see it in in in autopsies of.
9:16 Yeah, 'cause obviously they didn't have all the scanners and things like that and right everything, but I wondered what they were seeing in an autopsy. Go ahead. And. Thank you. So what's crazy is it didn't behave exactly like any other contagious disease. Some Some families had multiple cases, others had none. Some families had people with the issue and the people without it. Even hospitals sometimes failed to see, always failed to see a clear transmission patterns. Numbers were staggering. Like I said, estimates suggest that more than 1,000,000 people were infected worldwide and over 500,000 deaths occurred. But the most haunting cases were not the ones who died, it was the ones who survived. Do you happen to remember the movie Awakenings with Robin Williams and Robert De Niro?
10:01 Just vaguely, but not really. No. I don't remember details. Maybe I have encephalitis lethargia? Maybe. Maybe so. Doctors begin seeing something almost impossible to describe. Some patients didn't sleep. Instead, they froze. They remained conscious, sometimes even aware, but unable to move or speak. Imagine being trapped by your own body. You can hear people talking, you can see the room around you, but you cannot move. You cannot speak. You cannot tell anyone you're still there. Nope. And that reminds me of those those situations. And we may talk about this in a future episode, but I think about this all the time because I feel actually really blessed and lucky, knock on wood, that I don't have this problem. But those people that go into surgery not anesthetized, but completely paralyzed and frozen and can't communicate that they're feeling every single motion being done to their body? So terrible.
10:54 I'm glad I'm not red headed. Let me ask though, when they were frozen like that could they eat? Or I mean, how did they stay alive? It didn't really go into that, but based on the movie, which I know movies take creative liberties. Yeah, exactly. Have license. They were able to the ones that I mean, some were able to do autonomic things, like, I mean, they were still breathing, for example. So they could they could you could put food in their mouth, they could chew it and swallow it. I imagine there were probably some who were on feeding tubes, things like that. One of the other things in the movie, and I'm sure this is dramatized, but I think it's a good example of how different this is than true paralysis. So Doctor Sachs, one of the things he does in the movie, as he's trying to figure out what all these patients have in common, he has a specific patient and he throws a baseball to her and she lifts her hand and catches it. I.
11:46 Remember that. Yes. Nothing else. No response. No, nothing. Just catches it. It's like now it's. There, right? I almost wondered too, you know, if something dangerous was coming at them, would they would they respond, you know, flinch or put their hands up or something like that with the ball? Yeah, yeah. Like that? Yeah. That's wild. There's a there's a story of a man who was in a facility. So one of the things that we'll also get to further into this episode is that a lot of the patients that were diagnosed in the 19, late 10s and early 20s were still patients in the United States, specifically in New York in the 1960s. And that's actually when Doctor Sacks did all of his research was in the 60s.
12:29 And there's a story of a man that was in that facility and totally like a statue, devoid of expression, devoid of anything, just expressionless, etcetera. And one day, a nurse or somebody dropped a loud metal tray. And as it hit the ground, he was startled. And he said careful. He said careful. And then went right back to nothing. He's so. Yeah, so it's like, so like, they're so there, right? Like, you just can't imagine. So doctors described them as sitting like statues, eyes open, faces expressionless, completely motionless. When they were in this condition, that became known as akinetic mutism. Others with this condition developed violent muscle spasms, strange eye movements and tremors.
13:15 Some experienced episodes where their eyes rolled upward uncontrollably called oculogyric crises. Many terrible. Yeah, it does. Many developed severe psychiatric symptoms, psychosis, delusions, uncontrolled emotional outbursts. Children sometimes experienced dramatic personality changes. Previously calm children became impulsive, aggressive or emotionally unstable, a phenomenon in physicians at the time called moral insanity. Oh boy. Wow, Yeah, the. The disease seemed to attack the brain's systems, controlling sleep, movement, personality, behavior. In other words, the disease attacked the essence of a person. Wow. Can you imagine?
13:56 You have, let's just say for, let's just say Juliana, right? Hey, Juliana, how you doing? You know, you're visiting her one day and she starts to have a sore throat, has a fever and it's feeling tired. And three days later, she is a statue. Like that's how it happened. Maybe not three days later I made that part up, but still, like that's how this was happening. This was going from a perfectly functioning human being to a sore throat with a fever and some tiredness to robot statue void. Right. Wow. Check in on me in a couple of days because I've got a sore throat and I'm tired. So if I become a statue tomorrow or three days from now, or at any point in time, please check in on me.
14:42 I will. I will. That's wild, and I'm excited to hear about vectors or any other transmission that I'm sure you'll indicate any minute now. Oh, any minute. So there were three phases of this disease. The one, number one is the SOB. I hate this word. The somnolent form. This is the version that most people associate with the disease. Patients become overwhelmingly sleepy. They can sleep nearly continuously, even when awakened. They drifted back to sleep within minutes, and some slept for weeks or months. Then there's the hyperkinetic form. Other patients developed the opposite problem. Instead of sleepiness, they experienced agitation, insomnia, uncontrollable movements, mania, psychosis. Some patients shouted uncontrollably, a symptom called clasomania, involving sudden screaming fits. And then there was the a kinetic form, perhaps the most disturbing.
15:34 Patients became rigid and motionless. They developed symptoms resembling Parkinson's disease, like tremors, stiffness, slow movement, loss of facial expression. Some eventually lost the ability to move entirely. You might ask, how did doctors know that these were all the same disease, right? We're talking about the early 20th century. How did they know, right? Well, and one of them looked like Tourette's too. I mean, yeah, exactly. Uncontrollably and for heaven's sakes. And what's crazy, sorry to use the word crazy, but what's wild about that is that. Yeah, that was my first thought and why I wanted to look into. It's a really, it seemed like a really big leap to be like these three things that I feel like could be potentially explained by other neurological diseases.
16:18 We're saying this is the same neurological disease that isn't any of those others, for example, narcolepsy or Eretz or Parkinson's. This question gets us into some fascinating detective work by early neurologists. Well, yeah, because I wonder too, if because it was also often when a new disease or disorder comes up, a lot of different things are put in the same bucket. It's like, oh, this sort of connects and that sort of connects, so it must all be whatever. But these things are so diverse I wouldn't be putting them in the same bucket. I wouldn't either. That's why I was like, wait a SEC. Yeah. And again, they could theoretically be explained by existing. Well, I I'm assuming that those three can. Those diagnosis existed at the time, but I imagine they did narcolepsy, turess and tarp Parkinson's.
17:01 I don't. Know and even if the even if the diagnosis didn't exist, the syndrome syndromes may have and they may not have called them the same thing, but there were still things going on. Right. So at first, physicians did not think these cases were related at all. Which makes perfect sense, right? The symptoms were too different. Some patients slept constantly. Some were hyperactive and agitated. Some became rigid and motionless. But several clues helped doctors connect them. The same early illness. Doctors noticed something striking. Nearly all patients began with the same early symptoms. Fever, headache, sore throat, fatigue, and then neurological symptoms followed. So this pattern suggested a single underlying illness attacking the brain.
17:42 The timing of the epidemic talked across Europe begin reporting cases within the same few years. Even though symptoms differed, the timing was identical. Patients appeared in 1916191719181919. This overlap suggested a single epidemic disease rather than unrelated conditions. And then, like I was saying, brain autopsies. Autopsies revealed that patients with all three forms of the illness showed damage in the same areas of the brain, especially the midbrain, the basal ganglia and regions controlling sleep and movement. So is there, I'm sorry, was was there atrophy or sign of infection or did it, did it say or just plain damage?
18:23 Yeah. It just said damage. So wouldn't it be interesting to see Mris on that now? Or CT. Yeah, seriously. Seriously So the Perhaps the most convincing evidence came from patients whose symptoms evolved. So some patients began with the sleepy form, but months later they developed tremors. Rigid muscles slowed movement. In other words, the disease transformed from the somnolent form to the parkinsonian form. Doctors realized they were seeing different stages of the same illness. Additionally, clusters of mixed cases hospitals sometimes admitted multiple patients at the same time within the same ward. Doctor saw one patient sleep constantly, another wildly agitated, another completely rigid. Yet they all had arrived at the same sorry, they all had arrived with the same early infection.
19:09 This strongly suggests 1DS1 disease with different neurological effects. Why did the disease look so different in different people? Modern neurologists believe the disease probably attacked different parts of the brain in different patients. For example, damage near the sleep centers would cause overwhelming sleepiness. Damage in the basal ganglia would cause Parkinson like symptoms. Damage in the emotional regulation centers would cause psychosis or screening episodes. In other words, it was the same disease, but its effects depended on which brain circuits were inflamed. Did it matter age? Did they notice the correlation? They were they were mostly young, they were mostly young adults and teenagers, which actually also accounts for why there were still patients in this center in New York in the 1960s 'cause they had also. Been young, right?
19:58 Interesting. Here's what's interesting The epidemic eventually faded. By the late 1920s, new cases became rare. But the story didn't end there. Many patients survived and developed post encephalitic parkinsonism. A neurological disorder similar to Parkinson's disease. Well, that's not fair. Yeah. So these are the patients that actually I think, yeah, exactly. These are the patients that ended up in these long term care facilities, right? They slowly lost their ability to move normally. Some became frozen in place, others developed uncontrollable ticks and spasms. Many were placed in long term hospitals, and there they remained for decades. By the 1960s, hospitals in the United States still housed dozens of these patients. Some had been institutionalized for 40 years. They were alive, but barely responsive. They sat in chairs or laid in bed, silent, motionless, like living statues.
20:50 And then a neurologist named Oliver Sacks arrived. Go. Ahead. So pardon me, were these symptoms, as they continued to stay in the encephalitis state, were these symptoms progressive or had the damage started and completed and then they just were suffering the consequences? It seems like the latter. It seems like the damage had started, had completed, and they were just kind of suffering the consequences. I mean, imagine being, I can't imagine you would be. You could be institutionalized for 40 years if it was a progressive disease, right? Think about somebody diagnosed, Yeah, it seems to be diagnosed with Parkinson's disease. They're not going to live for 40 years after they're. Diagnosed. Yeah, that's. True, we wish they would, but they're not going.
21:31 To right, right. And that's another thing I guess you could say you could that would set it apart from Parkinson's is that they aren't dying it shortly thereafter. Their prognosis, they probably didn't know it at the time, but their prognosis is better than with Parkinson's. I mean well. It's kind of. As far as staying alive, that's what I was just going. To say, I mean, I'm thinking I'd like an end date, yeah, but yeah, so. Doctor Oliver Sacks worked at a hospital in New York that cared for patients who had survived the encephalitis lethargic epidemic, and at his time in the hospital he learned about a new drug that had just been developed called L Dopa. He thought that it might help them. So I don't know how L dopa. I should have looked this up, but I didn't. I don't know how L dopa relates to our current drug, levodopa.
22:13 I was wondering. Yeah. But I imagine. Yeah, sure. That would be great. I imagine it's similar. It may even be a predecessor to it. But that precursor. Yeah. Because I know that levodopa is commonly used in medicine now for neurological disorders. Mostly, I believe my mom takes it. Parkinson's, yeah, and I think Huntington's also, and maybe ALS, I'm not sure. So L dopa increased dopamine in the brain and doctors hoped it might treat Parkinson's disease. So Sachs decided to try it on his patients. And the results were astonishing. Patients who have been frozen for decades suddenly woke up. They began to move, to talk, to laugh. Some walked the first time in years. Caveat, I would love to know if they walked for the first time in years, how did they not have severe muscle atrophy? How did they manage that?
23:06 Because I mean, if they truly did not have muscle atrophy, then that was some really good work by the hospital staff to keep those muscles. And just for insert point L dopa does seem to stand for levodopa Levodopa. There we go. Yeah. Sachs reported that it was as if they had been released from a long sleep. And he documented, like I said, these extraordinary cases in his book Awakenings, which was published in 1973. But there's sad news. The miracle was temporary, and many patients experienced severe side effects. Others relaxed. Still, for a brief moment, they returned. I cannot imagine wake. OK.
23:48 But like, let's really stop and just think for a moment. Truly, we're kind of old to wake up after 40 years, probably. But I mean, I guess we could even, we could even, let's just go back. Well, it's hard, it's hard to do this, this finding this thought experiment because we know exactly what happened between the 80s and now. But let's just say we fell into a deep sleep in 1980 and we woke up in 2021. Of the things I like to do when I go home to Utah is I like to drive around my old to this day, I like to drive around my old neighborhoods and I like to see what's different and what's the same, right? And of course, over the course of 50 years of life, lots of things have changed. Of course, some things have stayed the same, but I would say more things have changed than have stayed the same, right? And I just cannot imagine.
24:35 I cannot imagine. For example, I grew up in an orchard area. The majority of the land that surrounded my, I lived in a little area of homes, but I'm surrounded by orchards. And so I watched as each of those orchards got subdivided, you know, and turned into subdivisions. And I watched that slowly year over year over year. And I cannot imagine, quote UN quote, going to sleep one day and living in, you know, surrounded by a dozen orchards and waking up the next day and suddenly I've been suburban or even semi urban hell. Right. Well, and if you think about it, even if you think about it from the perspective of someone who had lived 100 years and the things they've literally seen and over time going, Oh my goodness, it went from this to that. And that's a long span.
25:27 I mean, obviously these people weren't 100 years, but when you think of all the changes that could happen in that time frame, and it makes me wonder too with, with the information that they woke up, how much did they perceive as they were sitting there? I mean, if people were coming in and as staff do their talk about current events and things when they're moving people around, 'cause sometimes we forget that people in a coma or something like that or vegetative state do actually potentially have hearing abilities. And so we'll talk about things that are not particularly patient related. And I wonder if some of that would have sunk in and they would have had some knowledge of of current events just based on that well.
26:11 I imagine that it probably is a case by case basis, but I do know that there is a story of a woman who was given the L dopa and they call it woke up. So I'm just going to call it that. I feel like it's a misnomer, but it's not my, it's not my science, right? So she woke up, and she immediately began telling stories about the 1920s as though they had happened yesterday. So she was still sort. Of recently happened, yeah, OK. That it that it air quotes recently happened that it actually happened in the 20s. You think about going back to the thought experiment, you think about all the things that have occurred since 1980. OK, We didn't have home computers. We certainly didn't have laptops. We didn't have cell phones. We didn't have cell phones that were home computers, right. We didn't have the Internet, we didn't have e-books. We I mean, we didn't have grocery delivery. I remember, I don't know if you've ever watched this because it's not necessarily a very, very popular movie, but do you know the movie The Net with Sandra Bullock? No.
27:08 So it's an early, I think it's early 90s. I'm not 100% sure but it's definitely like pre Internet being common. And one of the things that happens in the movie is she orders a pizza from her computer. And I remember at the time thinking that is the most ridiculous thing. Like, that is just so silly, so sci-fi silliness, right? And we've done that how many times? The last 6. Months, right. Exactly, exactly. The last six months, Right. And so, yeah, so it's just like that all those things would happen immediately in a link of an eye. I can't. Remember. And it's and think about the psychological shock of that. I don't even know. I mean, I, I, I know, I keep being, I'm always like this in our episodes. I get speechless because I just, they're just, it's so unimaginable because I don't, I mean, I've woken up and it was 6:00 PM instead of 8:00 AM and that's psychologically shocking.
27:58 And then, and I'm not trying to make light of it because it is right. It's like, oh, no, wait, what? Or like when you woke for. A week and and you go, wow, I've missed everything. You know, nothing really has happened. Exactly. I I cannot imagine. And then the other thing that is interesting is Doctor probably could not have gotten away with treating these patients today like he did in the 1960s because it was experimental and really he had no guardrails when it came to when it came to these this experiment. And so, yeah, you're right. Exactly. It's interesting to to think and I know, OK, this is another scene from the movie. And so I know, again, just to reiterate, I know that movies take artistic liberties.
28:40 But in one of the scenes, he'd been given permission by his superiors or whoever is in charge of giving permission to give the patients a specific dose. And I think it was 30 milligrams or something of the L dopa. And he's seen sneaking and giving one of them 100 milligrams. And and that's when this patient wakes up, right? And so did that really happen in real life? I don't know. But again, you get to the ethics of there was nothing to stop him other than somebody giving him permission to do less and him doing more, right? Right. And again, you wouldn't get AI don't think he'd honestly get away with it, but I don't think he'd be able to. I don't think that that he'd be given that option today. Yeah, there are definitely different rules around testing and things like that than there used to be.
29:25 Not wild Wild West anymore as much. It is not. So I thought that I would share some stories of some of these patients. So the first patient, like I said, was just was discovered by Constantine von Kanemo in Vienna in 1917. And he was the first to describe the illness. And he encountered a young woman in Vienna. She arrived at the hospital with what seemed like an ordinary infection, headache, fever and exhaustion. Then she began sleeping. Not normal sleep, deep, nearly continuous sleep. Hospital staff could wake her briefly. She would answer simple questions, but within moments, her eyelids would droop and she would drift back into unconsciousness.
30:07 Days past, then weeks. Eventually she died. During the autopsy, Van Ekonomo discovered inflammation deep within the brain, particularly in regions that control sleep and movement, and this observation was the what became the foundation for recognizing the disease. One of the most haunting cases recorded in early medical in early medical literature involved a teenage boy in Germany. He had originally developed a mild illness with fever. Then his body began slowing down. His movements became sluggish, his face lost expression, but soon he sat completely still for hours. Doctors described him as resembling a statue in a museum. He could move if strongly encouraged, but every action required enormous effort.
30:50 Walking became nearly impossible. Eventually he stopped speaking altogether. The doctor believed he remained conscious but locked inside his own body. This form of disease later became recognized as post encephalitic Parkinsonism, which mimicked Parkinson's disease decades before most people had heard of it. So I was wrong. Parkinson's didn't exist as a diagnosis. Awkward. Awkward. I'm not surprised 'cause I think that's more modern. Those things are more modern. Diagnosis. No worries. Another disturbing case was described by physicians in France. A young girl recovered from the initial sleepy stage of the disease. Then something strange began to happen. Without warning, she would scream loudly, not out of fear, not in response to anything around her, just a sudden explosive screaming.
31:34 Doctors called the symptom. I said this before klasomania, meaning uncontrollable shouting. The episodes could occur dozens of times a day. Between episodes, she behaved normally. This strange symptom became one of the clues that the illness was affecting the basal ganglia, a part of the brain that regulates movement and emotional expression. Well. Of course, the most famous cases are the ones documented by Oliver Sacks in the 1960s in a hospital in New York. He described patients who sat silently in wheelchairs. So they sat silently in wheelchairs. They showed almost no movement. They rarely spoke. They sometimes seem unaware of the world around them. But then, like I said something occasionally something remarkable would happen. A nurse might say their name, or music would start playing, and suddenly the patient would move or speak briefly, as if the person inside was still there.
32:17 After being given the L dopa, one patient began walking through the hospital hallways after decades of immobility. Another started telling stories from the 1920s as if the intervening decades had never happened. That would be the weird thing. Yeah, it would. These are more interesting cases. One of the most dramatic early cases described by neurologists involved a young woman admitted to the hospital in Vienna around in 1917. And like I said, she also arrived with symptoms that seemed familiar to any physician of the era. Headache, fever, sore throat, exhaustion. Of course, the doctors suspected influenza or a routine infection. Then she fell asleep. The nurses tried to wake her for meals. They could rouse her briefly, but she would not stay awake even long enough to eat.
33:00 She'd open her eyes and then drift back into sleep within seconds. Doctors quickly realized this was not ordinary sleep. Her body temperature fluctuated unpredictably. Her eye movements were abnormal. Her reflexes were sluggish. Days passed, then weeks. For nearly six weeks she existed in a strange, half conscious state, sleeping almost constantly. Doctors would wake her only briefly for feeding and basic care as much as they could. Then, suddenly, just as mysteriously as it had begun, the sleep ended. She woke up fully awake and alert. She had no memory of the previous month and a half of her life. What in 1917? One died, one just woke up. But she remembered nothing about the experience. Nothing remembered, nothing about the experience. Well, so then that sounds like a coma state, except that. She could answer, she could briefly answer questions, She could sometimes eat just like it was like this trash coma almost, you know?
33:58 Wow. But she didn't. Remember, she didn't remember any of it. She didn't remember that she had eaten or had her bed bath or whatever the case may be. Well, it's interesting to me too that there was uncontrollable fever. So that does indicate maybe Teria load. Yeah, another chilling case involved the 12 year old boy in London during the early 1920s. Before the illness, his parents described him as gentle and shy. He loved books. He was quiet in school. Then he became sick with fever and fatigue. Sound familiar? At first it seemed like a minor infection. But after recovering, something about him had changed radically. He became impulsive, aggressive, restless. He'd been shouting and running through the house. He stole food from the kitchen and ate compulsively.
34:39 He screamed for no reason and sometimes laughed uncontrollably. Sometimes he raged. Doctors observed strange neurological symptoms, rapid eye movements, muscle spasms, uncontrollable shouting, and this behavioral transformation shocked physicians. Children with encephalitis lethargica sometimes developed what doctors at the time called post encephalitic personality disorder. Today, neurologist sleep inflammation likely damaged areas of the brain involved involved in sorry and I I know I've said this, I'm kind of repeating myself, but involved in impulse control, emotional regulation, behavior. In other words, the disease had literally rewired his brain and changed his personality. Many children who survived the epidemic experience lifelong behavioral and psychiatric changes.
35:23 So. What's interesting too to me just as a whole moment when a child is developing the amygdala and hippocampus and all of that are still processing their development. So it's not surprising to me that if at that, those moments of development they're damaged, then that will prevent or even stop altogether the emotional developments they would normally have if this was not affected. For sure. That's wild. It's. Yeah. So not a good way. No, not a good way. So perhaps one of the most haunting stories comes from the survivors treated decades later by Oliver Sacks. And this patient is portrayed in the movie by Robert De Niro. This patient had contracted encephalitis lethargica as a teenager in the 1920s. After the initial illness, his body gradually slowed. His muscles stiffened.
36:12 His movements became extremely slow. Eventually, he could barely move at all. By the time he reached adulthood, he was almost completely motionless. He sat in a hospital chair for years, then decades. Visitors described him as silent, expressionless, frozen. He remained in the state for over 30 years. Then, in the 1960s, when Sachs administered the medication L Dopa, something remarkable happened. Within days, the man began moving. Within weeks, he was walking through the hospital halls. He began talking, laughing. He asked nurses what year it was. They told him it was the late 60s. He was stunned. To him, the world had been 1926 only moments ago. He began asking about events and people from the 1920s, unaware that decades had passed.
36:56 For a brief period, he seemed fully alive again. Now in the movie Doctor Sachs takes about like shows in the world. I don't know if that happened or not. There's nothing mentioned about it in my research. He did eventually relapse and was basically back to how he was. Immobile, expressionless, modeless, motionless. Does it say how long it took for that to happen? The relapse. It didn't. I didn't. Well, it may not that I saw so. Now, what was interesting is because a couple of them you said we're almost immediate, the relapse was like, it almost seems like there was a jump start to the brain and maybe it connected things for a minute and then and then it. Stops which? Makes me wonder how the L dopa works just. What I was wondering, I was wondering if like the the L dopa goes in and it tells the brain, hey, more dopamine and the brain is like, oh, thank you finally I needed this. And then somehow maybe the brain rejects it. Maybe the brain processes that first dose or those first doses and it's like, this is so cool.
37:49 And then it's like, this isn't dopamine. Right, we recognize it. Or maybe it builds up a tolerance? Yeah, maybe. Yeah, I don't know. So how? What was the cause? Right? Unfortunately, guess what? We don't know. We still don't know. We don't know, but here are the theories theory #1 the 1918 flu, Spanish flu pandemic. I said this epidemic occurred around the same time. Some scientists believe influenza may have triggered the illness, possibly through an immune reaction attacking the brain, but no definitive evidence has been found. One of the things I would like to say about this is that having been having gone through COVID twice and recently, which, which I podcasted a lot of COVID, I am experiencing some of the symptoms of, of long COVID. And one of those symptoms is fatigue. And I think I've told you that there are days I'm going through this crazy sleep situation where there are days when I could barely keep my eyes open at 2:00 PM and I've got to finish work, you know, until 6:00 and then I'm to bed, I'm done. And then there are days like the other night where I can't sleep at all.
38:49 Like I'm tired. It's typical insomnia. I'm tired, I'm yawning, all the things. I just can't sleep because it all came about, came upon me after I had COVID. I'm I'm certain it's long COVID. Am I self diagnosing? Yeah, sure. But I feel confident. I wonder for the. Win. In fact, I didn't. Use Redmond DI. Use the Cleveland Clinic. No, I'm just. Kidding. Of course. Of course. But it makes me wonder if there's the same relational sort of situation right to the Spanish flu. Putting it out there simply, maybe this this encephalitis is long Spanish flu or something. I don't know, just a thought I had. Yeah, well, it makes sense. It seems like there could be some sort of crossover or some sort of latent influenza virus that hangs around and then gets reactivated for whatever reason. Theory #2 Autoimmune disease.
39:33 More recent research suggests the disease may have been autoimmune. In other words, the body's immune system mistakenly attacked the brain. Some modern patients with similar symptoms show antibodies targeting brain receptors. I personally don't buy this because it happened in such a cluster and autoimmune diseases are not contractible or sorry, they're not contagious. That to me doesn't make any sense. I'm no scientist, I have not been studying encephalitis lethargica, but I don't, I don't think that makes sense at all. That's just, again, it's the clustering more than anything. If you, if you tell me there's a cluster of people with fibromyalgia or a cluster of people with Hashimoto's or we don't typically see that, right? And again, there were some families that everybody in the family suddenly got.
40:14 It was so sudden and everybody suddenly got it and they got it at the same time. It wasn't like every person in the family when they turned 13 suddenly they had these symptoms, right? It was all at the same time. But I don't. That's not my, that's not my prediction, but. Others believe that it was a just an unknown virus that caused the epidemic. No specific virus has ever been identified. The reality is there may just be a virus that affected millions and we can't explain it. Viruses. Are also if you think about it though, I was listening to a podcast about cancer and how in my particular family situation we have the Roc Rocca 1 gene which makes us less able to fight off certain types of cancer because we already have a damaged gene sequence. So it makes me wonder when things like this happen that see so random and don't make any real logical sense if something along that line could be true.
41:07 However, like you said, with a cluster, if there's like 12 people in the family, it makes no sense to me that that gene would be triggered all at the very same moment for all of the same people because, because there are environmental factors too. Because my twin sister and I had a different experience with this genetic miscoding, if you will, where I actually received a cancer experience and she did not. And we're identical twins. So if the trigger is the light switch turning on or off because we both turn 46, then that would be one thing. However, with our environmental factors, whatever that look like, that may have pushed me faster. Although, you know, I don't know what those factors could have been necessarily. But I mean, I lived in Utah for longer, so maybe there were factors there that.
41:52 You live by Geneva Steel. Exactly. And there were five people in my neighborhood that were diagnosed with cancer within 2 1/2 weeks in that neighborhood. So I don't think it's some of it is a coincidence. So we have those environment factors and other sorts of things that may have triggered it. But again, we weren't all both on the same switch at the same moment. O12O5 OK, time to get a cancer. Gene, now you have cancer, right? Right. Who knows? It's just one of those things we don't know. So could it happen again? Well, they're all just worried that it could. The encephalitis encephalitis lethargica epidemic appeared suddenly. It spread globally and then it vanished and only rare cases appear today, scientists debate still, could the right virus or immune trigger or something caused something similar again?
42:37 After all, many neurological disorders do begin with infections and seeing the same parts of the brain being affected. And again, I'm sure, like you had already said, I'm sure that people with this disease are now diagnosed through Mris and CAT scans and PET scans maybe or whatever. But, you know, people probably thought that after the Spanish flu or pandemic that another pandemic would never happen. And yet, you know, 100 years later, here we had the coronavirus, COVID-19 pandemic. So could it happen again? Sure. Will it happen again? Probably. It may not look exactly the same, but that's kind of the nature of viruses in and bacterial infections in our existence, right? Like that's just kind of the course of life. Well, what makes me kind of ponder things is when you were talking about Tourette's like symptoms or Parkinsonian type symptoms.
43:27 I wonder if any of these things morphed into that. I don't know, maybe. Especially because we don't know what the trigger is. Was it viral? Was it bacterial? We've got proof over time that even some parkinsonians is not genetic, but it's more environmental. You've got a lot of people from, say, Southern California or places that have sprayed a lot of toxins on their fields. And the incidence of Parkinson's and other neurological disorders are higher potentially because of the load of those damaging chemicals. And I'm thinking about places that maybe have high metal content in their water or their surroundings and how that could have contributed. They still just don't even know. Well, and there's been some evidence, I briefly mentioned it before, but there's been some, some evidence autoimmune disorders of thyroid occur that kind of in a cluster around Geneva Steel in Vineyard, UT. And of course, Geneva Steel is gone now, but those of us that grew up before it was gone where it was spouting God knows what into the into the atmosphere, right like. And it's just the place we know 'cause they're. Right, That's what I say.
44:31 I was thinking about that. There's Pennsylvania is like steel USA, right? It'll be interesting to see if that same pattern. I just, I'm just talking about Geneva Steel 'cause it's what I'm intimately familiar with because I grew up next to Geneva Steel. And well then you have the work there exactly. And then you have the locations that I believe were in Michigan where their water, yeah, Flint, MI and those of environmental factors. I wonder how that plays. And when you look at these clusters, and I don't know, somebody probably already thought of it because I don't know that I'm especially that much of A genius. But did they look at where the environment was? And I know we talked about vectors, which are the transmission motors really, and not in the cars, but in the of the spread of bacteria or viruses where they're an animal or they're an item or how it transfers.
45:24 I wonder if there was any real study on that. But it sort of sounds like if there was only 1,000,000 worldwide. Well, that sounds like a big number. That's really hardly anybody. Yeah, well, it's comparison to the world. Yeah, you're right. Yeah. But another thing to consider is that a million people were infected and think about how many families, family members that impacted even the family of let's say 3, let's say an only child, which I'm sure not all the patients were only children. That's that. Are jumps into 3,000,000 just impacted? Yes. And not definitely not to say that it didn't impact people in a very strong way, but when you're talking. About I'm not, I'm not insinuating that's what you're saying. I'm just saying like it's, well, when you're one of the million or one of the three million, it's a big deal. It is a big deal, for sure.
46:08 What I'm wondering, though, is, as we've talked about in other episodes, was their sample group big enough to really get a good, solid look at what could have been causing it? And it sounds like not because it sounds like it was spaced out far enough and it was diverse enough except for in small communities that it but I wonder. If there was really any organized coordination back in the early 20s, right, like it virtually disappeared in around 27. And again, we had these long term patients in that we know about in New York 60s. But if it disappeared or or virtually disappeared in the in 27, then it seems like maybe people stopped. I'm actually, that's the next thing I'm going to say is that this is considered the forgotten epidemic.
46:53 And it's considered the forgotten epidemic because it's rarely discussed outside of neurology and medicine. And again, at its peak, it affected millions of of people, hospitals filled with patients trapped between sleep and wakefulness. Some died, some recovered, and some sat motionless for decades, alive for some time. And so, you know, how much research has been done into the, you know, I don't know, I don't know how much research has been done into it, but I do know that it's also probably quite difficult to research something that went away. Yeah, and like I say and with the such the small population groups, yeah, but it's it would be interesting to see if there is anything that it that was the precursor of anything.
47:36 But I don't know how it could be possible to figure it out because there is such AI mean when you're talking a gap of what, 60? Anyway, a long time. Remember how we don't math a full couple of generations where there probably wasn't anyone affected? Back again to me thinking that if they don't have the part of the illness that they're sleeping or unconscious and maybe skipped right to a Parkinsonian sort of presentation, then would it have just been put in Parkinsonian bucket versus the encephalitis lethargia? I don't know. This is so fascinating. And in order to study it, you'd have to have a whole lot more power behind it than I do. Yeah, for sure.
48:18 So, in closing, encephalitis lethargica remains 1 of medicine's most haunting mysteries. A disease that appeared suddenly, spread around the world, transformed personalities and bodies, and then disappeared without explanation. It reminds us that even today there are illnesses we still do not fully understand. And somewhere in the history of medicine, there are stories of patients who waited decades for a chance to wake up. Wow, fascinating. Thank you so much. You're very welcome. All right, if you've made it this far, clearly you like a little mayhem with your medicine. Or you just enjoy hearing us ramble about weird medical mysteries. Either way, we'd love you for it. So hit that follow or subscribe button wherever you're listening. And toss us a rating or review while you're at it. Helps other curious weirdos find the show. And we know there are a lot of you out there. Oh so many.
49:07 Come join the chaos. Thanks for listening to Medicine, Mystery, mayhem, and sometimes Murder. Do you have an idea for an episode of this podcast? Just want to say hi? You can get in touch with us at our M4 pod. That's OURM thenumberfourpod@gmail.com. We read every e-mail, and sometimes we even respond just like real professionals. Because we are old. Friends with new twists and lots of body bags.