Ep. 60: Who Are You?

What if the name on your birth certificate was never yours?

This week, Andrea and Crystal dig into one of the rarest crimes in America: babies taken by strangers and raised as someone else’s child, kids who grew up with no idea anyone was searching for them. From a Harlem pediatric unit in 1987 to a Cape Town maternity ward, a Fort Worth babysitting ad, and a Chicago hospital in 1964, we follow the paper trails, schoolyard coincidences, and DNA matches that finally handed these children back their names.

Along the way, two nurses ask the hard questions. How did women posing as staff walk out of hospitals with newborns? What changed in infant security because of it? And when the truth finally comes out, who do you love: the family you were born to, or the one who raised you?

Featuring the cases of Carlina White, Kamiyah Mobley, Zephany Nurse, Melissa Highsmith, Paul Fronczak, Baby Holly Clouse, and Lisa Jensen.