Welcome to M⁴: Medicine, Mystery, Mayhem... and Sometimes Murder!
May 25, 2026

Ep. 36: The Roof, The Roof, The Roof is On Fire

Ep. 36: The Roof, The Roof, The Roof is On Fire
Ep. 36: The Roof, The Roof, The Roof is On Fire
M⁴: Medicine, Mystery, Mayhem... and Sometimes Murder
Ep. 36: The Roof, The Roof, The Roof is On Fire

The Clinic That Burned: The Cleveland Clinic Fire of 1929

One hundred and twenty-three people went to the doctor. They didn't come home.

On May 15, 1929, a fire broke out in the basement of the Cleveland Clinic, one of the most respected medical facilities in the country. But it wasn't the flames that killed most of the victims. It was the gas, a toxic cloud released when nitrocellulose X-ray film ignited, that moved through the building faster than anyone could run. In minutes, a place built to heal people became one of the deadliest disasters in American medical history.

In this episode, Andrea walks Crystal through the fire that shocked a nation, the science behind why it was so lethal, and the lasting changes it forced on hospital safety, film manufacturing, and how we think about the hidden dangers inside the buildings we trust most.

0:06 Welcome to M4 Medicine, mystery, mayhem, and sometimes murder. I'm Andrea Marziano and RN with 35 years of experience across various fields. From direct patient care in hospitals to home health, geriatrics, and injury medicine, I face life, death, and everything in between. And I'm Crystal Miller and RN with 13 1/2 years of experience. My work spans home health, Hospice, emergency care, geriatrics, and occupational health. From the chaos of trauma based quiet moments with patients, I've seen stories that defy explanations. We've been friends for over 25 years and as nurses we've shared countless stories that have left us and our families speechless. Now we're bringing those stories and many more to you in medicine, mystery, mayhem, and sometimes murder.

0:53 Each week, we'll uncover cases that challenge the boundaries of medicine, sharing the human stories behind the science. From puzzling medical mysteries to shocking real life crimes, we'll bring you stories that'll leave you questioning everything you thought you knew while. We're both experiencing. Nurses, we want to make it clear we're not here to give medical advice. This podcast is about storytelling, education and exploration, not diagnosing or treating medical conditions. This is medicine, mystery, mayhem and sometimes murder. Let's dive in. Hey Crystal, how are you doing? I'm doing OK, how are you? I'm also doing OK. Tis the season for congestion I suppose. Yeah, tis the season for being sleepy all the time too. Just tis the season anyway.

1:36 Hey, I wanted to tell you I've been having some interesting events because we're planning a family reunion and planning a family. We're planning a family. Wow. Yeah, Yeah. And the family happens to be mine, but we're going to do a family reunion. My dad decided a month or so ago that he wanted to see if we're all interested in the family reunion with his adult children and our children and our grandchildren. The total event. Well, and there's only he only had three children and we have 25 people going. So I was thinking of like family that there's 14 zillion children and then another 14 zillion grandchildren. But it's been such a challenge to find a location that A everyone can get to and B can accommodate all of us. Yeah, I'm sure.

2:21 It's interesting because as I was looking at the different places on VRBO and Airbnb and all those things, they say they could accommodate 40 people, but then they've got the beds that you have to have five people in one bed. Or you trundle. Beds, Yeah, yeah. Or mats on the floor and things. And I'm like, that's not exactly what I had in mind. But the place that we did find an reserved and paid for yesterday, there's ten different bedrooms plus a left with bunk beds. So it's pretty exciting, and it's got a theater room and it's got ping, it's got a garage and it's a beachfront property, so that's pretty cool. Yeah. And it's in Bear Lake. It may still be a little chilly when we go out there, but I think it'll be a lot of fun and we've got enjoy. A Raspberry shake for me.

3:02 Oh, I will. And what about the huckleberry? Oh, I've never had a huckleberry shake. I've yeah, 'cause Huckleberry's Berry. Huckleberry's gosh. Huckleberry is Berry, Berry, Berry. Yes, and it's very common in Idaho and we'll be in the Idaho part of Bear Lake, just just over the border. We have huckleberries here actually in Washington, which I hadn't realized. We also have have a lot of different berries that go around here in the winter and the Nope. Gosh. Are you Andrea? Are our brains working well enough to record this today? Absolutely. Why would it be any different than usual? All right, we'll give it a go. All of our listeners who are loyal, please remain loyal. Yes.

3:45 Our lovely listeners. Goodness. Well, today we are going to talk about the Cleveland Clinic X-ray fire of 1929. I've never. Heard of this? That's exciting. It is. And when I first started looking at it and looking at the different sources, I thought, oh, that's not really enough information to talk about for any period of time. But as I kept looking, I found a lot more really information, informational sites. I know, sorry, you weren't supposed to notice that little flip. Anyway, as I started to research further, I found much more information. And some of the things that I'm going to talk about are quotes I'm going to read because they're really quite harrowing and the things that people experienced.

4:30 So my sources are the clevelandhistorical.org site, the case dot EUEDU articles at Cleveland Clinic and it's Cleveland Clinic disaster themagazine.clevelandclinic.org and this was their Centennial article and it was titled Grief would be defeat. One of the doctors said that if they just if it had succumbed to grief, then it would be defeat in the whole situation. Sounds intense. Oh my gosh. The final article with that was newyorktimes.com. It's titled Poison Gas Kills 100 in Cleveland Clinic Explosion. It was actually more than 100, and we'll talk about that a little bit of time here.

5:11 The incident happened on Wednesday, May 15th of 1929, and it was just a regular day in the Cleveland Clinic. The way I read it, it looked like it had both clinic offices, like many hospitals do. They had clinical offices in the hospital itself. There had been a pipe in the sub basement that had been leaking steam because, you know, a steam will be running through the hospitals at that time. It would have probably been heat primarily, but also for going to the line laundry and and taking care of other sorts of issues. But there had been a leaky steam pipe in the sub basement and this basement had been converted from a coal bin into a storage room for the hospital's X-ray film. And one of the things when I read that statement, I thought, gosh, I wonder if the conversion of the room had anything to do with the volatility of the film in the room itself.

5:59 Because I sent some pictures to us in our chat, which I'm hoping you'll put in the show notes, but I can't put pictures. In the show notes, I we're going to have to figure out another way to do that. Probably a probably a Patreon actually. OK. Well, anyway, listeners, I'm sorry to hear that because I wasn't sure, but one of the pictures in the research that I did had what was the coal room, and I wondered if there was any coal left, any debris of coal, because it's very hard. Even if they got the large pieces, I would be really surprised if they worked hard enough to get all the dust and everything, and that can become quite combustible as well. Reading on later, it sounds like that may not have been as much of A contributor as I thought perhaps it would be, but it was a thought I had because it seems like that would add to the volatility altogether. Anyway, the steam fitters name was, I loved his name, Buffery Boggs.

6:51 Wow. Yeah, it is a cool name. Buffery Boggs. He was trying to close the steam leak, but when he went in there, he encountered clouds of thick smoke that were already pouring from the exposed pipe. That was weird because it was supposed to be a steam pipe. Well, he tried. He looked at it, and he realized that there was a fire going, so he tried to put it out. He and an assistant custodian were working on this, but they couldn't. They couldn't put it out, so they tried to escape, and what they experienced was the first of several explosions. What happened for them, though, is it knocked them both through a basement window, which allowed them to scramble to safety. Oh my.

7:33 Goodness, I know. I was just sure that he would have been smithereens. But no, just by whatever person wants to call it luck, fate, whatever, they were thrown out the window and I would imagine they still sustained some injuries, but they did not die. So that was wild. What happened is the smoke, the gas that was in this room because of the film, then created two more violent explosions. The whole clinic was wrought. It practically blew off the roof. There's a picture involved that showed that the roof was gone. What was interesting to me is that from the outside the building looked pretty much normal because from the sides it looked OK, but the roof had blown off.

8:17 Which I thought was interesting too because if they were in a sub basement to have the roof blow off seemed really odd to me. But that was part of the shaking of the clinic I guess and these explosions were pretty bad. Problem was the explosion itself probably wouldn't have killed anyone or a few people anyway. There were no people I I saw a report of that were killed due to the explosion. However, the explosions forced deadly fumes at a high rate of pressure through the pipe tunnel system, and the pipes ducted into nearly every room at every floor on the hospital almost immediately. So that was the problem because the smoke was, they said it was yellowish brown.

8:58 It also got into all the major stairways between each floor. And what happened is that caused the trapping of 225 occupants of the hospital at that moment, and many of them had immediate death from this cloud of yellowish brown smoke. The pressure from these explosions caused the walls to bulge and windows to burst all over the place. There was one picture that showed a room, an office room. It looked like the ceiling was bulged down. It was like so. Strange like sucks like suctioning being suctioned down. You know, maybe I actually considered it coming from the other direction, but what you're saying may have made more sense because it looked like I'd been sucked down, like there was the middle of it and just kind of bulged. It was very odd.

9:45 I did not include that in our pictures. It was, it was fascinating. Many of of the people at the time of the explosion were in bed because they were in hospital. Because they were patients. Patients. And there were people in operating rooms, so they were on these people were in operating tables. The doctors and nurses were actually working. It was just a regular work day. I believe it was at 10:32 or something in the morning. So people were just doing the hospital things. The toxic vapors caught most of the victims by surprise because the way I read it, the explosion happened, basic vapors went entirely through the hospital. People were collapsing at their desks. People had taken one or two steps to escape, then they died. They just, people were everywhere, just Keeling over and dying.

10:31 There were 123 victims that almost instantaneously died. So I guess on the one hand, that's good news because. If you're going to die, instantaneous is the way to go, right? They counted the victims as 80 visitors and patients, 43 employees and 92 people were injured. That's a lot all at one time. Doctor John Phillips was a founder of the clinic and head of the medical department. And he died because he was in the clinic and he had the toxic gas inhalation. A few of the victims were able to escape the hospital by being rescued by firemen, policemen or volunteers. Some people were able to climb out windows at the lower floors, and I mean at the lower part of the building and that sort of thing. But if you can imagine too, these people, many of them, the ones who were in the beds and in the operating room, they really didn't have an option to depart easily and possibly could not. Many of the people who had had any amount of the fumes ended up dying from the toxic vapor.

11:33 Some were soon after or immediate there and others didn't die for several days. And the ones who took a couple of days to do that, that was quite. There was a woman called Eva Morgan and she was a nurse, the Lakeside Unit. She was working as a receptionist in the waiting room. It had been told that she had tried to calm the hysterical parents patients and she went later to the hospital building and she collapsed after she helped a few more patients. And so she just collapsed and then she died. It was interesting that she could work for a while, help some people and then collapsed and died. And then it was said that William Brownlow, which was the head of the art and photography department, had taken the day off. But he returned to the clinic to retrieve a forgotten item and while he was there the main explosion happened. He stayed to help.

12:27 He was smashing the window on the 3rd floor to help people get out to a ladder. During these rest efforts had breathed the fumes and died. Jeez, please. Yeah, it's interesting. There's a bunch of quotes that I'll tell you later. But they also mentioned that the telephone operator, Gladys Gibson, died at her desk with the cords on her switchboard plugged into lines throughout the building. She had remained at her post to alert the others to the emergency, but she could have easily escaped through a window just a few feet away to try and tell as many people so they could get out. And if you remember, there were 225 people in the building that they could account for, and 123 of them died. Wow. Yeah, the ratio was very high. There was a nearby fire company and they were the first to respond. Said that when they arrived, most of the building was obscured by this dense yellow brown cloud. It was said that that cloud stayed around the building for a full 2 hours, that it was visible. Wow.

13:20 Which makes me think that the invisible particles probably were there for even longer. For longer, yeah. It didn't say, but I wondered how long these particles stayed and where the particles once they fell and were no longer gas. I wonder if it didn't say anything about them still being contaminated, like when people went in later to investigate, didn't say anybody got sick at that point. But it made me wonder why or if later maybe there were some other consequences to that. When they have a big fire explosion like that, you know, they're they send out more alarms for more firefighters and rescue swads and stuff. They raised ladders to evacuate people who were appearing at the windows. And I guess there were people that were behind closed windows, just tapping on the windows, trying to get out because they couldn't break them. Firefighters were trying to get up there. Because they were thick?

14:07 Or do you know why they couldn't break them? They didn't say exactly, but I wonder if it was because they were failing, The people were failing already where they just didn't have the strength. That's my thinking. Again, another very serious thinking by Andrea, because there were some details that were pretty strong and other details when I looked at the various sources, they didn't. I think things happened so fast it was hard to tell what was going on, but all available fire trucks, equipment and personnel were sent to combat this fire in deadly fumes. Several of the firemen were standing on top of the hospital to try and figure out what the damage was and other providing aid. And I think at that point they still were really not totally sure what the exact damage or problem was while they were still trying to figure it out.

14:54 But it did become very apparent that the lower corridors would block the passengers. I mean passages. Gosh, listeners, I'm sorry, my brain's not working. Very. Well, today's episode is Juice, your own adventure. You design what Andrea means. Choose your own, yes. Anyway, they didn't think they could enter anything with stretchers or they were having people go in and come out just gagging and hacking and dying because they had gone into the building for just a few moments. The chief in charge of this whole thing was Chief Graham, and he ordered home motors that were brought into the building.

15:36 And I wasn't totally sure what that is, but the way they described it, it sounded like it was those big fans to aerate. And also they had firemen handing hoses around. They were beating back flames. But they were also, at one point, I read as part of the story, they pushed the fume clouds away with these hoses. So they essentially just knocked the clouds down with the water. That way the people that were able to come out could walk to the ladders. They also started using respirators, both the firefighters and the people. Thank goodness. Gee. Yeah, they brought them in and that's one of the things later that we'll find out was changed on Fire Rescue trucks, because at that point they had not yet started using respirators on the trucks.

16:19 They didn't have them. There were some personal reports from the rescuers that I wanted to read before I go into any more of the other details. Some of the firemen were turned back by the suffocating gases, like I said, but they finally were able to reach the top of the building by motor controlled ladder. 2 of the firefighters, Howard McAllister and Peter Rogers, said they hacked their way through the skylight, fastened ropes under their arm and were lowered into the building. And they had to swing themselves to get enough momentum to drop inside the mezzanine rail. Now I'm thinking about dropping into a building, into a mezzanine rail on the walkway that circled the entire 4th floor. So they came through roof.

17:02 We're trying to drop onto this walkway at the 4th floor, so if they had missed or fell, they probably would have died just from that because that's 40 feet. Anyway, they got in and they said they found bodies packed deep in the space between the elevator and the stairway. Yeah. Trap door on the roof was cracked open and 15 victims were lifted up to the roof. So that's they were able to get there, but then they couldn't get out. So they were the firefighters were able to crack it open and, and lift these people out. Several of the people who are crushed at the bottom of the pile were dead, but a number were still living when they were pulled out into the air. They were unconscious, but some of them recovered after getting some oxygen, both in just the regular air, oxygen and then oxygen pumped into them.

17:46 That result wasn't very common. Chief Graham was lowered into the building and he found the crushed bodies. About 10 people had been trampled to death in the Stampede to reach the elevator. Yeah, it makes me think of 9/11 9. 11 Yep, exactly, exactly where my mind goes to. Yeah, Chief Graham said. This is a quote. As soon as the smoke had cleared a little and we could see our way around, I noticed a man sitting in a chair in the lobby on the second floor. He looked as though he had just started to take a short nap when the fumes began rolling through the building and caught him. It was so fast that he was sitting in the chair in the lobby. Now maybe he hadn't started in the chair in the lobby, but that maybe that's how far he could go. Chief Graham said it just looked like he was taking a nap. Chief Graham also said I found one of the nurses seated in her chair at one of the second story offices.

18:30 She seems to still be alive, but we worked with her for over an hour without bringing her back to consciousness. Wow. And Fireman was noted to put on a gas mask and he groped his way in and a minute he staggered out and he said can't make it, it's killing me. And this was the gas mask. He moaned and fell into the arms of the chief. And then the chief was continue on saying they were screaming figures on the roof. They were dimly seen through the rolling orange huge fog. So I guess at that point it gone from yellow to orange. And he said there are whales coming from the windows, people wailing, automobile horns Tooting. And spectators, he said, were quivering in groups and they were gasping. It's. Fascinating that spectators came. You would think that they would run away from it.

19:12 It's odd that they all gathered to. It and we'll talk about that in a second but they heard the explosion so I think that's what drew them I. Don't know if I saw noxious yellow and orange plumes of fumes and no rhyme tendon. I don't think I'd approach. I mean, maybe it's a nurse. I would right? That's a whole different story. But I, I mean, I'm thinking also from 2026 perspective, I would demand a respirator and I wouldn't go in lungs are blazing. But it just seems I can understand the desire to investigate an explosion, but I can't understand sticking around once you see these noxious fumes. Yeah, and actually they stopped sticking around once they saw the noxious. Fumes.

19:53 OK. Apparently fumes were they were visible from above, but apparently the people on the street hadn't yet seen them. We'll talk about a couple things that happened there when one of the things. Louis Hildebrand was a fireman, and he called him the ladder to the roof, and he said he rushed to the skylight and looked down. And Graham, the chief who was in the building already said, this quote was a little confusing to me, but he said down the airway quick. They're trampling them to death down there. I don't know if that meant he wanted an airway sent down. I'm not really sure, but that's what he shouted, Hildebrand said when he looked down in the skylight. He said, I hope never to have to look at anything so horrifying again.

20:35 He said, Lord help me as far as far down the stairway, you can see where bodies, bodies, bodies, twisted arms and legs, screaming, men and women, bodies and screams. Yeah. I know, I know. And the patients there were 30 or more of them, he said, were jammed so closely together during the frenzied flight to the roof that they couldn't move. That is actually, if I were to have a fear, this is the one of being trampled or being stuck where I could get out technically, but I couldn't because I was crowded in with people who are panicking. And that is that is probably my biggest. I don't know if it would be considered a phobia but is probably my biggest fear. Interesting. I've been in a lot of like, mosh pits and, and I've been in situations where crowds are not necessarily panicked, thank goodness, but definitely are excited and pressing. And I've been, you know, out of control of my movement. And I can understand your fear because it's really scary. And fortunately, as you can tell by the very virtue of me being here, I've never been trampled to death. That's true.

21:36 It happens a lot. And there's just the, yeah, just this panic and desire to get anywhere but where you are. Yeah. Yeah, well, and there's been incidents even at after Christmas sales where people have been trampled to death because people are so excited. To get yeah, yeah, yeah. Wanted to get that $40 TV. Totally worth it to me. I'd certainly helpful people to get Is stumble a word I don't know but I should be. I've used it before, stumbled. Anyway, that's what was happening here. Some of the firefighters, they didn't quote this as a specific person, but they were saying that some of the people were without clothes and were only protected with sheets wrapped around them.

22:18 Glass was being hurdled from the skylights to the second floor foyer. So I imagine here you are trying to run out of this poisonous gas and a fire and explosion and you've got a sheet and glasses raining down on you that. That's the thing that I can't, I can't just dismiss and walk past because a glass cut is so painful. You know, you and to think of the idea of glass raining down on you or jumping through a window that you've just broken or any of those things or being blasted through the window like the the first two guys, I just can't. I can't imagine how excruciating that must be to have so many glass cuts. I was working one time at the Utah Valley Hospital in Utah. I was a nurse probably 3 years at that point, and I had a student that was preceptoring with me and there had been a very big car accident out on the road just outside the hospital, which in one hand was very convenient because they could bring them right in.

23:10 But there were multiple people involved. Not a ton of people, but I think there were 5 or 6 people that had glass injury 'cause this was before all the windshield glass was the pebbly stuff. Yeah, so it was real glass. A lot of people were. It was a college town. People were driving old clunkers that were even older than the day. I know that I was working Med surge with my students and everyone was called to the emergency room that could go. So there were a few nurses left on the floor. And the people, those of us who had preceptors, brought them because the students could sit and pull the glass out of. My goodness.

23:51 Yeah. And they were little. I remember them being those little shards and yeah, splinters of glass. Right. Right. My student looked at me because, I mean, it wasn't technical work. It was just like, pull this out of their skin and then we had to dress the wounds and such. It was really uncomfortable for the people. Of course, they all got medicated, but it was still uncomfortable and also scary. We had to check eyes to make sure they didn't have glass in their eyes and that kind of thing. I know, I know it was, it was rough. And my student kept looking at me like, I don't want to do this. I'm like, I get that, but do not do 'cause you can't just leave it some with blast injury, a lot of it will work its way into the skin and then have to work its way out. It's just, it's not best to dig it out because if you cut it all out, that would be even worse.

24:37 But anyway, that it reminded me of that too when I was thinking of the glass. And also, if you think about the fact that they don't have clothes, they probably don't have shoes either. Yeah, you're. Yep. Oh, go. Ahead. I know that would be terrible. Chief Graham also said it took three firemen to force a way down that stairway, that there were people all in. For 5 minutes. We were lifting those bodies to the skylight before we could just get to the third floor where the screaming was the worst. Oh God, I know. PTSD, right? Seriously. I just seriously just bumped my screen. There was no reason to panic. Don't panic, everything's OK. Take a deep breath. But when the firemen could get down to the third floor, they were, as I said, clamoring over debris, clothing, scraps of plaster, and they found a panic stricken group of patients that were trying to get down to the first floor.

25:25 As in many of those situations, they didn't know whether should go up or down, but they were trying to get to the first floor. The victims were being brought out by the firefighter and they were coming out so fast that the workers on the street and the front lawn could hardly treat them fast enough because obviously they weren't prepared to deal with. This is going to sound like I'm joking but I'm truly not getting the the bodies or the people. If they were alive out on the roof, were they tossing them down to the crowd? How are they getting them to people? Well, I think they were using that mechanical ladder that they were, I've seen it before where they, a firefighter will hold a person on the ladder and then it'll go down and and that kind of thing because they had no other way because this. Was interesting as fast, right, like they're trying to go as fast as they can.

26:11 And so walking them up and down ladders seems like it. I mean, I guess you could do like a conveyor. So the situation, it's not a ladder maybe and pass them down. But I just yeah, yeah, I, I it's an honest question. Like I just wonder what they did to be as expeditious as possible. So they brought some up, but mostly they were bringing them down because what I read is they had that small group of 15 people that have gotten to the top, but all the rest have been coming down. So they were coming out the front door, these patients. And people go up the twin towers also. Just because they didn't know, because they could tell things were crashing below them, so they didn't know. Those things happen so fast. I just can't even imagine. Some of the patients when they were bringing them out said, no, I'm fine, I'm fine. And one man said you don't have to do a thing for me. And a fireman was trying to give him fresh air, you know, and also give him oxygen.

27:02 He said the gas didn't bother me. Get the others who are dying and this guy. 5 minutes later he collapsed and died. Wow, his body was OK. Serious gas man. He had been lifted into an ambulance at that point because they were still taking him and he was dead before he reached the ambulance. It was crazy. There was a report that man named Paul Rokermore of Dallas, TX was an X-ray salesman in the clinic at the time of the explosion. He was able to get out unassisted. He turned it once and he was helping the firemen. One of the rescue, Scott said. You better get to a hospital. You don't know what the gas can do. Paul worked for a little while helping people. Then he went and presented himself to the hospital because he was told to. He said I'm here and I'm here for treatment. He was laughing about it because he thought he was fine. It's really 10 minutes later, he was dead. Oh yeah, it's.

27:50 Crazy. You know what the gas was. Yeah, we'll talk about that in a couple of minutes, OK. It's hard because this was before there were regulations and rules about pretty much anything. And this was a motivator experience to make some rules. But the largest number of people killed in anyone place were caught on the stairway, like I was saying, and in front of the elevator on the 3rd floor. The firefighters had a really hard time with that, seeing that. Because I'm guessing the elevator didn't say use stairs in case of fire. Probably not. Also, after an explosion, I don't think I'd want to get on an elevator because for heaven's sake. Go down into a ball of fire. I don't know. I would rather have taken stairs, but then again, the stairs were clogged up with dead bodies, so got to do what you got to do, I guess. One of the things that the fire Lieutenant Reese, his name was TW Reese, said that not more than one or two of the people who rushed to the elevator came out of the building alive. Reese said When we smashed in a window at the West side of the building, we can see through the smoke one hot huge pile of people.

28:54 They keep talking about huge piles of people. 123 people died and I wondered what a huge pile of people would look like. Yeah. I mean, was that 10 people, 12 people, 30 people? I don't know because I guess any pile people would be too many for me. But I don't know when they say that. I'm not sure what to envision. But like I say, any number of people in a pile dead was probably more than I'd prefer. I mean. It's not pretty but like my mind goes to mass graves filling fields and like Auschwitz and stuff. Me too. They talk again about a fireman. Who bored a hole through the smoke with a high pressure hose? Three other people in that same area pulled bodies from the pile and carried them to the window.

29:37 That's where other firefighters waited to take them to the ground. That was probably the bio. The bodies being removed was probably after, of course, they brought the people who were appearing to be alive out, Lieutenant Reese said. We had a line of people strung from the hallways to the stairs where they were trapped clear to the window, and it looked like a hopeless job to begin with. Everybody seemed so entangled in the pile. Not a one of those we dragged out appeared to be living. The firemen found that there was only one they thought was still living in one of the crush that they found, and she was a nurse. They carried her to an office at the east side of the building and they closed the door to block the smoke as much as they could. Then they broke a window to let fresh air in and they started applying artificial respiration, but she died while they were trying, so that was really hard, said. One of the largest heroic efforts was made by a policeman, Earnest Stabbed, who was recorded as saving 21 lives. During this fire and event.

30:42 He seemed to recover and return to duty as a policeman, but he collapsed while he was working on his lawn. He was near death. I know they didn't say where or how long afterwards because it did seem like he had fully recovered, but he was near death and he was rushed to the hospital and placed under an oxygen tent. And he endured recurring medical problems for the rest of his life as a result of the clinic disaster. But he did remain on the Police Department for another 20-5 years. He served as a detective. So he was taken off like a beat patrol as a detective. But it's just interesting to me that we'll talk a little bit more, like I say in just a second about what happened to these people as a result of this smoke.

31:26 The people who did appear to air, quote, survive. So many of them thought they were OK and then they weren't. And then I think back to things like Agent Orange and stuff that had long term effects. Dozens of witness reported that the bodies of the first victims coming out were yellow as they came out and then they turned green after they were brought out the building. Some sort of oxidization, I guess. I don't know, but Can you imagine looking at a person that looked a little yellow and then they turned green? No. Also a back to I'm getting the heck out of here. Yeah, seriously. I was thinking back to our toxic lady Gloria Ramirez, when people started falling down around her from from the exposure. I'm like, I am not staying, thank you very much. One of the things it said is there was a massive group of onlookers and they blocked the area for five blocks in every direction.

32:22 Also, I'm thinking if I'm in a group of five block deep people, even if I wanted to leave, I don't know if they could have said that. Pedestrians that were outside the building toppled to the ground and they were laid unconscious until they were dragged to safety. When the gas lifted, all these people come rushing up because of this explosion and then people start dropping and then they were dragged to safety. So at that point, hopefully people moved away. It's just wild that they were hanging out, you know? Oh, let's just see what else might happen. Let's. Just watch this insane thing happening. Well, and. Watch these green people be pulled out of this building. I. Know and let's stay see what happens.

33:02 Let's stay Interesting to me too, because I'm thinking if people were around the whole building for five blocks, that's, I mean, how many people is that? But if people were coming out the front of the building, the people in the back may not have even known what's going on still. So they could have who knows? But in 1929, there were a lot less options, I guess, and communication and all of that. Lot less, A lot less. A lot fewer options for entertainment. That's right, that too, I guess, probably. Oh my goodness, there were a lot of physicians on the scene. Of course, 'cause it was a hospital and a clinic. A physician called George Creel recognized that the injuries were similar to the ones he said he witnessed in World War One, which poisonous gas caused a highly fatal lung edema.

33:53 I guess the inhalation of what he saw there created inflammation in and around the lungs. I wondered what that looked like exactly, but I guess it's like a pneumothorax. I'm almost thinking where there's. Pressure outside the I would imagine, too, that the alveoli probably swell, right? And so they crowd crowd each other out. And they can't move, which would be a very unpleasant way to go. Yeah. This is where that report of the grief would be defeat. Doctor Corel was back in the operating room by Friday of the same week. And he said, what day did it happen? Saturday, I think. No, it would have been a weekday. I don't recall.

34:34 I'm sorry. Wednesday. No, it was Wednesday. OK, so Saturday I was just trying to figure out how many days Saturday was. OK, so he was back in the operating room 4 days later? Yeah, he said. Grief would be defeat, he told his wife Grace. And he said this has come to us and we must build something constructive out of it. Jeez. What an attitude. PMA Buddy. Yeah. Jeez Louise, slow clap. Yes. Oh. Man, I know it was reported that Doctor Carl Helwig was an intern at a different hospital, but he went to Mount Sinai where they had taken a lot of the injured. He was resuscitating victims. And then he came upon his wife and she had gone to the clinic for an examination and she died as he worked to save her. That sucks.

35:22 Big time. I can imagine, man. I know it didn't say if he knew she had been there or not, but the way he said it said he came upon his wife sounds like it was a surprise. And when I was working in American Fork Hospital, I was again on the Med surge unit and we had a person who had been doing Hang Gliding at the point of the mountain there. And I think I've told you the story, but he slammed into the mountain and he was in the ER Everyone was working on him. I had been called to come in as an IV team person. I didn't actually do the IV because someone else had come in and gotten it before I could get there. All of a sudden I had gone back to my unit and all of a sudden there was this huge scream through the hospital because it used to be a very small hospital. It was the wife of the guy on the table. She had been working on him and didn't know it's just her husband.

36:13 Oh my gosh. I know. So it just reminded me of that, that it was the same experience because he was unidentifiable. They had found his wallet. Anyway, he died. I thought of that when I heard of Doctor Helwig and finding his wife and then working on her. She, of course, I imagine looked like herself, except for possibly green. They said that it was just impossible to find any room for beds or cots at Mount Sinai because they were just so crowded with people. Because you have to consider there are another 100 or so people that had come, hundred, 102 people that had survived and many, many, many of them had come to the hospital for assistance. Especially people who like the guy who ended up dying on the way, or several people who died on the way because they thought they were OK and anyway it just meant well. It's not like 100, it's not like 100 people came and needed a Band-Aid either, right?

37:03 Like 100 people came in critical condition with mystery poisoning. Right. And I don't even know if they never did say if there was any kind of reversing agent for this because I think basically they died before they could have done anything else anyway. So even if they could have figured something out, they did put the one detective police officer on oxygen and that helped him recover. But that was the only thing that it seemed like held anyway, at that point at Mount Sinai, the cots were in the hallways. Janitors and other staff were helping to apply the artificial restoration. Oh my gosh, respiration to the victims and treat for burns because also fire. It was still a fire.

37:49 So they were treating burns. They were doing everything they could. All the medical people, everyone in the hospital was helping. Can you imagine getting burn treatment from a janitor? What's your training? Well, I. Imagine. Yeah, yeah. I mean, which is great that they could help, but can I just, oh, it's, I can only mildly visualize what kind of chaos this happened to Ben. Also, they were nurses and doctors coming in that were injured and hurt and dying, and they were saying a priest was going around giving last rites to those who appeared to be dying all through just wandering around giving last rites to everybody who's dying. It was just crazy.

38:32 And again, many of the people died on the way to the hospital. They couldn't administer care quickly enough to all they tried. They tried everything they could. And so people were dying in the hospital just because they couldn't help them fast enough. The police had to work with the people who are coming in looking for their loved ones. And they had just the city was filled with fear because they didn't know who had been affected. They didn't know who was there. This really is like a miniature 9/11, right? Like. Yeah, it really was. So similar, I mean, other than to be a terrorist attack, of course. Right. And it did make me wonder if they thought it was something like that. But I think it's before terrorist attacks really happened. So I don't think that was ever considered.

39:12 Also, since the guy who was trying to close the steam was there when the first explosion happened, I think they knew pretty fast what had happened, but they hadn't yet figured out why. So the police had to go to the morgues and hold people back because the bodies were being taken in and they hadn't identified everybody yet. They didn't know who was who. It was just crazy. So they started, as they started identifying people, they thought they identified people. People had to come to actually from the family, identify the bodies. They said the scenes were heart wrenching and heartbreaking because people were hysterical and they had to be LED from the building that some people just walked out silently, tears down their faces. And 123 families were affected.

40:01 And of course, how many people does that really mean? Thousands. Probably thousands. Did you go to Art's funeral? No SO. His funerary work was done poorly. And I'm just thinking like, if I had had to identify him, I could have identified him alive. So I, you know, when he was in a coma and all that, and I had to identify him, then I could have identified him. But if I had had to identify his body and it looked the way it did in his casket, I would have been hard pressed to say that was him. Yeah. So I can't even imagine having to identify a body that's also green and has God knows what, what injuries and wounds and what have you. I just. I can't imagine.

40:42 Yeah, I was in California during that time for your family. I forgive you. Just kidding. Thank you. Thank you. It would have been so traumatic and tragic, and I wonder too, if all of this was happening, were there people that they could never find? They never said anything about it then, especially people. The opposite people they found, who were never identified. Yeah, it could be. It didn't say anything about any of the stories I read saying that. Again, I wonder back in 1929, it's not like they had DNA testing or anything like that. And I imagine with the various explosions and the the degree of fire, I couldn't think that there wouldn't be at least some people that were lost that were never found.

41:25 But yeah, I don't know. So after the disaster, community leaders came to the aid of the Cleveland Clinic because it was a pretty impactful clinic for the area. They had done a lot of research and a lot of things like that, and there were gifts that were totalling more than 30,000, which is the equivalent of nearly half, $1,000,000 today. They gave them to the clinic to help rebuild, but for reasons that I never actually saw, the Cleveland Clinic opted to return the money and they finance their own recovery. That's weird. I know it didn't say why, but I thought that was interesting and they even included interest back to the people who paid. It so weird.

42:08 Yeah. And I think that maybe the founders of the clinic were very committed to making I, I felt like maybe the things they said, it almost sounded like they didn't want any government interference or anything like that in their clinic. And that was an extrapolation I made by having them give it all back, because it had been the community leaders that brought this money in. So I don't know. I just guessed because I didn't see anything specific about it or why they gave it back. The surviving founders, one of the doctors that was a founder was killed in this. But the challenges, they said were huge. They were responsible for the human and financial losses, the challenges, rebuilding, and then also talking to the crowds. They're angry and grieving.

42:56 And there was also a lot of legal stuff that went on even back then. And they were all trying to return to work. So the fact that they returned this money and didn't they didn't use it is weird to me. Like you said, it seems like it would have made some of it easier, but I guess they didn't want to be beholding to anyone. I don't know. Yeah, I guess. It was just sort of interesting to me when I read that. Oh my gosh. And interest, I'm not really sure what motivated it, but it sounded like they held on to the money in case they needed it, and then they returned it when they realized they didn't. Maybe they had their own fundraisers. They never really said they. Raised far more money than they needed, so they just turned it to be ethical. And again, like I say that it may have also been just to not owe anybody outside of their own clinic. Thanks for looking that up.

43:44 They had a variety of investigations, of course, to find out what was wrong. And a doctor. McLaren was a commissioner of the city trade waste department, which I don't have any idea what a trade waste department is. I've never heard of it since. So maybe it was an older thing, but he was one of the first investigators on the X-ray film storage room. OK, so AI don't think I'd want to be one of the first people in there because I'm still going. What the heck? I just maybe they didn't consider it could still possibly be toxic. It didn't say he went in wearing protective gear or anything, and maybe he did, but there was a picture of a bunch of guys that were another wave investigators, and they were just standing there in the prison suits ready to go in.

44:26 Like, no, thank you. I feel like that would be dangerous. He initially saw a light bulb hanging from the pipe duct, and he said it was hanging precariously, and he theorized that that was the primary source of decomposition to the nitrocellulose film. What had been the problem? So a little bit of. His light bulb lit the film. Well, that's what he was thinking. He was thinking it was decomposing it. But here's a little history about this nitrocellulose film. And this film was developed by Eastman Kodak Company. You've heard of Kodak, I'm sure. And it was developed during the late 1880s. And it was for use in the field of medicine for doing X-rays and in the motion picture industry. So it's the same film.

45:08 This film developed a reputation for being highly volatile, oh boy. And unstable. And extraordinarily flammable. Wow. So those are really good features, yes, especially the. Stack up in a storage room. Exactly. That had coal dust in it, Yeah, and precariously hanging. I was saying apparently poorly, poorly young lights. Yes, can't see anything going wrong there, but it noted in the research I was looking at that if the nitrate film ignites, it's extremely difficult to extinguish, and even better, immersing the burning film in water may not extinguish it and could actually increase the deadly gas that's emitted.

45:54 Oh my gosh. And they knew that. Here's the room in the basement that has all these films stacked in it. Some of it I get was probably exposed film where they'd already use it for X-rays, and probably storage of said film because where are you going to put it? Oh, I know we'll put it in the basement. This is volatile, deadly stuff. Jeez. I know. Now, did investigators know that this had been set up this way before? Probably not. Nobody probably even thought about it because I would not be surprised if the people that had stored it were people unaware of anything like that. Because usually somebody says, hey, go put this somewhere out of the way, OK?

46:37 Yeah, we got to find a place to store this. I'll clean out the basement. Problem solved. Exactly. Which is reasonable because if I didn't know it was highly volatile, I'd probably just stuff it in the backroom somewhere too. I don't know, Yeah. Yeah. But there were representatives from the Ohio Inspection Bureau. They were among some of the people that were sent to investigate what happened. The team came up with three viable theories as to the cause of the fire. What they concluded, one of them was the light bulb. They didn't mention what this second theory was, but the one they concluded was that the steam acted as the primary catalyst, that the light bulb probably wasn't actually involved because remember how water can make it more unstable? So the steam that was coming out, it got on the film and it made the highly unstable nitrate film start to decompose, and then it started to emit a poisonous cloud of gas that is not good, and then all of that. Sounds pretty bad.

47:34 Yeah, it's as in many of these things, it had that perfect storm of things that happened that if one of them happened, it probably wouldn't. OK. But when all of the things happened together in a sub basement, it could have been something that could have probably put itself out or something. But the fact that it went into the exhaust system, because in this basement was also the heating ducts and everything that went through the whole hospital. And that was the problem. Yeah. And I mean, but who would think that that could ever possibly happen? I don't think anyone. This was the most intense disaster that happened in any hospital or clinic facility ever recorded at that time.

48:14 It really got the attention of people everywhere in the national, worldwide. I'm sure they're going, oh, that seems to be a problem. What happened that was good is in many of these cases they started looking and investigating, going, oh, there might have been some little problems here. The National Fire Protection Association, which was already developed, so that's good, said in a report. This is the quote the most diabolical cunning could scarcely have devised, an arrangement more surely calculated to spread death throughout the building. Wow, sorry guys. Said the. Janitor who packed up the films.

48:56 I don't know. Maybe that custodian, I don't know. But yeah, they said even if somebody planned this, they probably couldn't have done as much damage as the situation caused. Never in the history of medical science in the world had such a strange disaster demolished another hospital or clinic. As I mentioned, even more than the loss of life, it caused the destruction of records, equipment, statistics, test specimens and delicate instruments. Because it was a learning hospital too, apparently. I was just going to say that's like doubly bad because it's a learning hospital. It's a research hospital. It's a forerunner in research as a research hospital. That's horrible. Yeah. So I mean, obviously the loss of 123 people is tragic, and then the loss of all of that was a huge, huge hit.

49:43 There were a lot of legal actions taken, but Cleveland Clinic officials were absolved of responsibility for the fire. There had been $3,000,000 in lawsuits. So if we know that 35,000 is, what was it $1,000,000 now a $3,000,000 lawsuit? Can you imagine that? How much is that? I don't even know. A. 100 billion 100,100,000,000 not billion probably a. Hundred, a lot of money, a lot of money. They were able to settle out of court for about $45,000. So that was still. That's very different than 30. Million, it is. It is, but it was still a lot of money back then. Sure, considering all that happened and you know, they never mentioned anything about talking to the Kodak Company or anything like that at that point. Because I think the Kodak Company should have had some responsibility here, especially if I mean, maybe there were warnings, but there if there were warnings, the people who were actually moving it like we're talking about probably didn't know anything about those warnings. Was it on the boxes or something? I don't know.

50:41 Probably not. Now we're warned, you know, something that's boiling hot could actually be hot back then. I mean, I think they just figured people were smart enough to figure it out. But in this case, I don't know why they would be. Not that they weren't smart, but that they wouldn't know. It's a niche thing to know. Right. And unless the person had actually sort of somehow heard about it, I mean, the city manager's Commission that was investigating the fire recommended that Cleveland's police and fire departments be supplied with gas masks and the municipal ambulance service be established to provide a suitable transportation for cases that needed transporting to hospital care. Because they didn't have any major response team, as it were. They didn't have anything set up for something of a toxic nature.

51:24 I guess they had just not had anything like that on a national level. The fire resulted in the development of new standards for storage and labeling of hazardous materials, especially the nitrocellulose film, because it took a while for them to come up with something else. I didn't see in this how long it took to change from that volatile stuff to something that was a little safer, but there were changes in how it had to be stored and how it had to be labeled. And now, gosh, if there's anything even minorly toxic, you've got to have data safety sheets on SDS. Yeah. And going, OK now, if you spill ammonia, you have to do this. If you spill this, if you use whiteout, it's every blasted thing. Fire insurance companies also began to revise and strictly enforce safety regulations regarding the sort of stuff like this, too, because the building insurance would have had to cover some of this if they had fire insurance. And as a hospital, I imagine they did. But that was one of the things when I looked at the returning the donations, they said that their insurance covered quite a bit of it and and so they just didn't want to take advantage of the public trust.

52:35 That's really nice because they sure could have, they could have gotten some better materials and stuff. So the insurance companies said, OK, so if you are responsible, then you get to pay for some of it instead of what was happening there. And also, you know, they wanted people to be safer. Several of the investigation commissions that were looking at the cause of the fumes made amendments to policy that they had for this sort of thing as well to alter firefighting practices and the procedures and methodology behind the proper use and storage of these chemicals. Like we talked about, it was paid attention to through the world because since this film, the cellulose film was the standard for taking X-rays, even people in other parts of the world had been using it.

53:20 So they had to they had to look at how they could keep people safe. And also, if you think about it, if you had these films in other countries that have even fewer guidelines than the. United States and resources and rescue resources, I mean. Yeah, it's probably just fortunate that nothing like this ever happened. Before, yeah. In a lesser developed country, Yep, yeah. It's just shocking and and the fumes are so scary to me because if it's coming out, what do you do? Those people can rush up to the scene, but people who were just innocently walking by and didn't know anything about it and didn't rush up to the scene that were passing out and collapsing, they had no time to respond either, it sounds like. Do you know if it had an odor or a scent? Nothing was ever said.

54:12 When I think of a yellow gas, I think of rotten eggs. Rotten eggs, right? Sulfur. But nothing was ever said about it smelling they just but I think it would have seen. I don't know though, because it seems like the guy that was like, oh, the gas didn't get to me. He would have thought that if it had an odor odor that he would have known he inhaled it, right? Probably. Probably. Maybe because there was not even a single solitary mention of anyone saying and then I smelled, you know, whatever. There was no one mentioned anything about smells and they talked about a lot of other stuff. So I would think if it smelled somebody and all of. Them. Then I smelled farts. And somebody or a burning match. Or whatever, Yeah.

54:55 A sulfur smell or something? No, nobody said anything anywhere about a smell when they had in that Centennial article. They didn't really bring anything out that I hadn't already read and all the other stuff. I think it was just one of those things that they were reminding of history, including Cleveland. One of the things I'm interested in talking about in a different episode of this pug. There was Collingwood school fire of 19 O eight in one of the articles that said it was the most tragic thing that had happened in the state since of Ohio wool fire. Yeah, of of Ohio in the school fire of 19 O 8. I did a little research on that, but I I'd like to have a separate episode that was really terrible too.

55:39 It's just amazing how fortunately a lot of rules and regulations have changed and sometimes having all the rules and regulations is like, are you kidding me? But many of them save lives every single day, and some of them are just stupid and obnoxious. But it means it saves a life, then I'm willing to do it. I just think that these things are so scary and tragic. And even if a person doesn't die, these firefighters and police that saw all this and, and the fellow people who did survive who saw all this must have been awfully traumatized for a while, I'm sure. I'm just glad I wasn't there. I am not old enough to have been in a 1929 experience.

56:21 These are the stories that are so amazing to me. And as many of our stories that have these sorts of tragedies, they are the leader of change because nobody realized this was as big a problem as it became. Fortunately, other people didn't have to experience it a lot like some of the other things that had to wait to change and tell enough people experienced it. But 123 people on one go is is a pretty big, pretty big hit. I'm glad that things have changed, hopefully in a way that this will never happen again. And of course, the cellulose film is gone by the wayside. You know, I wonder actually, as I say that, I wonder what happened to all of it that was around. I wonder.

57:06 I wonder where it went. Probably some landfill volcano. Yeah, who knows. As would be typical of those years, and probably until probably until the 60s at the earliest, nobody worried much about putting toxic stuff anywhere. Yeah. So that's a thought I don't want to carry on with anyway. Well, thanks for listening. Yeah, thanks for sharing. It was great. All right. If you've made it this far, clearly you like a little mayhem with your medicine. Or you just enjoy hearing us ramble about weird medical mysteries. Either way, we'd love you for it. So hit that, follow or subscribe. Button wherever you're listening. And toss us a rating or review while you're at it.

57:46 Helps other curious weirdos find the show. And we know there are a lot of you out there. Oh so many. Come join the chaos. Thanks for listening to Medicine, Mystery, mayhem, and sometimes Murder. Do you have an idea for an episode of this podcast? Just want to say hi? You can get in touch with us at our M4 pod. That's OURM thenumberfourpod@gmail.com. We read every e-mail, and sometimes we even respond just like real professionals. Because we are. Old friends with new twists and lots of body bags.